Retail Competition under the WIC Retail Delivery System: Insights from a Spatial Competition Model
Reject/Resubmit at Journal of Retailing
A spatial competition model of how WIC's retail delivery system shapes pricing incentives and consumer welfare, and how e-commerce changes these outcomes.
Abstract
The Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants, and Children (WIC) delivers food benefits through a retail delivery system. As this system ties WIC benefit redemption to WIC-authorized retailers while insulating WIC consumers from the retail prices of these foods, concerns have been raised about whether the system affects retailers’ pricing incentives and generates price spillovers borne by non-WIC consumers. We therefore develop a spatial competition model to examine how this system shapes retail competition and analyze three market scenarios with different levels of e-commerce involvement. Our model shows that exclusive access to WIC demand leads WIC-authorized retailers to set higher equilibrium prices for WIC-approved product categories. These higher prices shift some non-WIC demand from WIC-authorized retailers to non-WIC-authorized retailers, raising the latter’s equilibrium prices as well, though to a lesser extent. Moreover, the price distortions are more pronounced in markets with higher offline shopping costs, lower offline retail density, and a larger share of WIC consumers. Given that WIC accounts for a substantially larger share of total demand for infant formula than it does for other WIC-approved product categories, the price distortions are likely to be more pronounced for infant formula. Turning to e-commerce, we find that e-commerce entry intensifies retail competition, thereby mitigating offline price distortions, improving non-WIC consumer welfare, and reducing direct WIC spending. Further extending access to WIC consumers, an ongoing policy initiative, directly improves WIC consumer welfare, but its effects on non-WIC consumer welfare and direct WIC spending are ambiguous and depend on the share of WIC consumers and the relative costs of online and offline shopping.